Tiptap vs ProseMirror vs Quill: pick your rich text editor in 2026
Tiptap, ProseMirror, or Quill for your rich text editor in 2026 — a practical breakdown for small teams who need to ship, not experiment.
Three developers in a ruko near BSD City’s Pasar Modern had this argument for two days before their tech lead picked Quill — which they spent the next four months regretting. The rich text editor decision looks small. It compounds fast.
This is a practical breakdown of the three options that come up most in Indonesian dev teams: Tiptap, ProseMirror, and Quill. Not a feature matrix from a vendor’s marketing page. An honest read on what each one costs you in time, maintenance, and edge-case pain.
Why the rich text editor choice still matters in 2026
Editors are deceptively sticky. You integrate one, write data to your database in its format, and changing your mind six months later means a migration. Delta objects from Quill do not convert cleanly to ProseMirror JSON. ProseMirror JSON does not map directly to Tiptap’s schema without manual work. Pick carefully the first time.
Comparison: Tiptap vs ProseMirror vs Quill
| Dimension | Tiptap v2 | ProseMirror | Quill 2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstraction level | High (headless, extension-based) | Low (primitive, full control) | Medium (opinionated defaults) |
| Setup time | Hours | Days–weeks | Hours |
| Extension ecosystem | Large, maintained | Community (fragmented) | Small, stalling |
| Collaborative editing | First-class (Yjs) | DIY or third-party | Difficult |
| TypeScript support | Excellent | Good | Partial |
| Bundle size | ~50kb core + extensions | ~90kb | ~45kb |
| Last major release | Active (2026) | Active (maintained) | 2024 (quiet since) |
| Headless / BYO styles | Yes | Yes | No (opinionated CSS) |
| Learning curve | Low–medium | High | Low |
Tiptap
Tiptap is built on ProseMirror and wraps it in a framework-agnostic extension system that does not force you to read 40 pages of ProseMirror documentation before writing your first custom node. It works with React, Vue, and vanilla JS. The Headless approach means you bring your own styling — useful when a client’s brand guide is strict or when you are building inside a design system with Tailwind.
The extension library is the main selling point. Mention, Collaboration, TaskList, SlashCommand starters — most of what a product team needs exists as a maintained package. The Collaboration extension (Yjs under the hood) works well enough that teams use it in production note-taking apps without building their own CRDT logic.
Where Tiptap struggles: the Pro extensions (AI, collaboration server, comment threads) require a paid plan. For bootstrapped Indonesian startups, the free tier covers most use cases, but collaboration at scale means either paying for Tiptap Cloud or self-hosting Hocuspocus. Self-hosting Hocuspocus on a VPS at Rp150–200rb/month works fine for up to a few hundred concurrent users. Above that, you need to benchmark.
Tiptap is the default pick for mid-career teams who want to ship a feature-complete editor without owning the primitives.
ProseMirror
ProseMirror is what Tiptap, Milkdown, Remirror, and Notion’s editor are all built on. That tells you something: it is the solid foundation everyone reaches for, but almost nobody ships it naked to their users.
The document model is genuinely powerful. Schemas are strict, the transform system is correct, and collaborative editing via y-prosemirror is well-tested. If you are building something non-standard — a structured legal document editor, a form builder with rich inline fields, a code notebook with mixed cell types — ProseMirror gives you primitives that higher-level abstractions do not expose cleanly.
The cost is real. ProseMirror’s API surface is large and the learning curve is steep. The documentation is technically accurate but written assuming you have already internalized how its document model works conceptually. Budget two to three weeks for a mid-level dev to become productive with it. For a three-person product team racing to launch a SaaS, that is a lot of weeks.
Use ProseMirror directly when you have a specific constraint that Tiptap cannot satisfy, or when you are building tooling on top of it intentionally. Otherwise, Tiptap already gives you ProseMirror — with a better developer experience on top.
Quill
Quill was the default answer for rich text editors from roughly 2015 to 2021. The Delta format was intuitive, the defaults were reasonable, and getting something on screen took thirty minutes. Many internal tools and legacy CMSs in Indonesian companies — agencies around Serpong Tech Hub, fintech apps built during the 2019–2020 growth wave — still run Quill in production.
The problem is that Quill’s development has slowed to a crawl. Version 2.0 shipped in 2024 after years of waiting, fixed some long-standing bugs, but the ecosystem has not recovered. Third-party extensions for Quill are largely unmaintained. Issues opened on the GitHub repo stay open for months. The Delta format, while elegant, creates a wall between you and any collaborative editing library — CRDT tools expect a different conflict-resolution model than Delta provides.
If you are maintaining a legacy Quill integration: keep it running, but do not extend it significantly. If you are starting a new project and considering Quill because it looks simpler: the simplicity evaporates the moment you need a custom node type, collaborative editing, or TypeScript support that is not bolted on.
Quill is not broken. It is just not the right answer for new work in 2026.
Verdict
Pick Tiptap if:
- You are building a new product and want an editor you can extend without owning ProseMirror’s internals
- Your team is two to five people who need to ship, not research
- You need collaborative editing at some point — Tiptap’s Yjs integration is the cleanest path
- You want headless styling that fits inside your existing design system
Use ProseMirror directly if:
- Your editor requirements are genuinely unusual and no Tiptap extension covers them
- You are building infrastructure or tooling that other editors will sit on top of
- You have a senior dev who can own the ProseMirror layer and document it for the team
Keep Quill if:
- You are maintaining an existing integration and migration cost is not justified right now
- The features you need are already working and you have no plans to extend the editor significantly
Avoid Quill for new projects. The stalled ecosystem means you will eventually face a gap — a missing extension, a browser compatibility issue, a framework update that breaks something — and find nobody maintaining the fix.
For most product teams in 2026, the choice is Tiptap. It is not exciting, but it is correct.
Ditulis oleh Asti Larasati